Bullhorn alternatives for healthcare staffing, and which part of Bullhorn each one replaces
Updated September 2026
Bullhorn describes itself as the AI recruitment ATS and CRM powering 10,000+ staffing agencies, and for healthcare staffing it goes well past recruiting: credentialing, a time and pay rules engine, shift scheduling and a provider mobile portal. So the first question is not which alternative is best, it is which part of Bullhorn you are replacing. Ployo replaces the front of the funnel. Ployo is recruitment software with a built-in applicant tracking system and an AI video interviewer that interviews every applicant the day they apply. It does not do timesheets, payroll, client billing or VMS, and this page is clear about where that matters.
If you need one system for recruiting, credentialing, time and pay and invoicing, Bullhorn or a healthcare-specific suite like LaborEdge is the honest answer, and Ployo is not a replacement for that. If your agency's real bottleneck is screening, too many applicants for travel, per diem and allied roles and not enough recruiters to call them, Ployo is our recommendation for the front of the funnel: Sarah, Ployo's AI interviewer, interviews every applicant on video the day they apply, and your recruiters get a Met or Not Met verdict on each must-have with the candidate's words quoted, from US$249 a month with no per-seat charge. For a full staffing platform other than Bullhorn, LaborEdge is built for healthcare, Ceipal and Avionté run front to back office, and JobDiva adds a back office suite and VMS synchronization.
A staffing ATS and CRM with Amplify AI and, in North America, middle and back office. Its healthcare offering adds credentialing, time and pay, shift scheduling and a provider mobile portal.
- Format
- Applicant tracking and CRM software. Amplify Digital Workers handle sourcing, screening and outreach; Amplify Search and Match ranks candidate relevance.
- Based
- Boston, United States. About 1,400 employees across 14 countries, per Bullhorn.
- Pricing
- Bullhorn Starter $99 and Core $165 per user per month, published on its pricing page. Pro, Max, Front Office Growth, Front Office Enterprise and Bullhorn One are quote only.
Side by side
| Bullhorn | Ployo | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | A staffing ATS and CRM, with middle and back office in North America. | Recruitment software with a built-in applicant tracking system and an AI video interviewer. |
| First-round screening | Amplify Digital Workers handle sourcing, screening and outreach around the clock. | Sarah, Ployo's AI interviewer, runs a live two-way video interview with every applicant and checks each must-have. |
| Credentials and compliance | Credential management, compliance visibility and a provider portal for uploading credentials. | Asks the candidate about registrations and checks on video and records the answer. Confirming them with the issuing body stays with you. |
| Time, pay and billing | Time and pay with a rules engine for FLSA compliance, holiday schedules and shift differentials, plus invoices. | Not offered. Ployo does not do timesheets, payroll, rostering, client billing or VMS. |
| Scale | 10,000+ agencies, including 22 of the top 25 healthcare staffing agencies, per Bullhorn. | Plans from 60 to 800 interviews a month, with custom Group plans above that. |
| Pricing | Starter at $99 and Core at $165 per user per month; larger editions are quote only. | Published in US dollars: Essential $249/month (60 interviews), Growth $850 (250), Scale $2,135 (800), Group custom. Interviews included, no per-seat charge. |
Choose Bullhorn if
- You need back office in the same system. Bullhorn's healthcare offering includes time and pay with a rules engine for FLSA, holiday schedules and shift differentials, plus invoicing. Ployo does not do timesheets, payroll or client billing.
- Credentialing is daily work. Bullhorn manages credentials and gives providers a mobile portal to view shifts, upload credentials and log time. Ployo records what a candidate says about a credential; it does not track or verify it.
- You fill shifts, not just roles. Bullhorn's AI matches open shifts with available, credentialed providers. Ployo has no shift scheduling.
- You want the category default. Bullhorn says 22 of the top 25 healthcare staffing agencies use it, which matters when you hire recruiters who already know the system.
Choose Ployo if
- Your recruiters are the bottleneck at the top of the funnel. Every travel and per diem posting brings applicants who each need a screening call. Ployo interviews every one of them on video the day they apply, so recruiters start the day with evidence instead of a call list.
- You want the screen to be a real conversation. Sarah, Ployo's AI interviewer, asks each must-have question, follows up on what the candidate actually said, and works in 23 languages on any device at any hour, so a nurse coming off a night shift can do it at 7am.
- You want proof you can put in front of a client. Each candidate gets a Met or Not Met verdict decided on the must-haves, with the verbatim quote behind every requirement, red flags on good-to-have gaps, and the recording and transcript.
- You pay per seat today and your team is growing. Ployo charges for interviews, not users, so adding recruiters, account managers or a client's hiring manager costs nothing extra.
- You want a lighter tracker for a new desk or a smaller agency. Ployo's built-in applicant tracking system covers job links, bulk CV upload of up to 25 files at a time, duplicate detection, stages from Pending to Hired, a drag-and-drop review board and an activity log, without a back office implementation.
- You want humans to own every decision. Ployo's automation only advances candidates, per job, and Ployo never auto-rejects anyone.
Candidates ranked by what they actually proved
The alternatives, and who each one suits
Ordered by the kind of buyer they fit, not by preference. Several of these are a better choice than Ployo for a given team, and the note says which.
Recruitment software with a built-in applicant tracking system and an AI video interviewer, Sarah, who interviews every applicant live on video the day they apply.
Best for: An agency or healthcare desk whose bottleneck is screening applicants fast enough, that wants every applicant interviewed on video with a checkable verdict. Not a replacement for credentialing, timesheets, payroll or billing.
Healthcare staffing software: NexusATS, NexusVMS, NexusMobile, NexusAI and NexusPay, with automated credentialing and Joint Commission audit support.
Best for: A travel or per diem healthcare staffing agency that wants a platform built only for healthcare, including VMS and payroll.
A staffing platform combining ATS, VMS, Ceipal AI and workforce management, with healthcare credentialing, compliance and invoicing.
Best for: An agency that wants ATS and VMS in one system and staffs both healthcare and other sectors.
End-to-end staffing software: CRM, ATS, payroll, billing, reporting and mobile talent engagement in one platform.
Best for: An agency that wants front and back office from one vendor, particularly one with light industrial and healthcare desks.
A staffing ATS and front-to-back talent management solution with CRM, onboarding, the DivaFinancials back office suite and VMS synchronization.
Best for: A larger agency that works heavily through client VMS programs and wants the back office suite from the same vendor.
Which part of Bullhorn are you replacing?
Bullhorn covers three jobs for a healthcare staffing agency. The front office is applicant tracking and CRM, with Amplify AI for sourcing, screening, outreach and matching. The compliance layer is credential management and a provider portal. The back office, in North America, is time and pay and invoicing; Bullhorn's homepage cites 1.3 million workers paid monthly through its middle office.
An alternative that replaces all three is a platform decision. An alternative that replaces the front office is a much smaller one. Ployo sits entirely in the front office, and it is fair to say so before anything else: if you are leaving Bullhorn because of its back office, Ployo is not your answer. If you are leaving because your recruiters cannot screen fast enough, it is.
The same answer, two formats
A first round is worth what it can find out. Both of these are real screening formats and both work; they differ in what happens after the candidate stops talking.
Typed answer
“One of our residents kept trying to leave at night. I sat with her, worked out she was looking for her husband, and changed her evening routine.”
Submitted, scored, and the interview moves to the next question. Written in private, at the candidate’s own pace, with every tab on their machine available to them.
Spoken answer
“One of our residents kept trying to leave at night. I sat with her, worked out she was looking for her husband, and changed her evening routine.”
And then, unscripted
“You changed the routine. Who signed that off, and what did you write in the notes?”
That second question did not exist until she gave the first answer. It is the one that separates a story a candidate can tell from a shift they actually ran.
Ployo: the front of the funnel, with the interview built in
Ployo is recruitment software with a built-in applicant tracking system and an AI video interviewer that interviews every applicant the day they apply. Applicants arrive through a job link, a bulk CV upload or a Gmail inbox pull that includes LinkedIn Easy Apply emails, and a repeat application to the same role is caught. Each CV is checked against the role's must-haves and good-to-haves, quoting the line behind each one.
Sarah, Ployo's AI interviewer, then invites every applicant. They book a slot or start now, reminders go out on their own, and the interview is a live two-way video conversation with follow-ups on what they said. Registrations, checks and availability are asked about directly and the answers are recorded; verifying them stays with your credentialing team. Recruiters see Met or Not Met on the must-haves with the quote behind each, move candidates one at a time or in bulk with undo, and mark the hire.
Plans are $249, $850 and $2,135 a month in US dollars, with 60, 250 and 800 interviews included and no per-seat charge. Buying starts with a call to the founder.
Full healthcare staffing platforms: LaborEdge and Ceipal
LaborEdge provides healthcare ATS, VMS and mobile solutions to staffing agencies, hospital systems and healthcare workers: NexusATS, NexusVMS, NexusMobile, NexusAI and NexusPay for payroll and daily pay, with automated credentialing and Joint Commission audit support. It is based in Novi, Michigan, and does not publish pricing.
Ceipal calls itself the Staffing OS: an ATS, a VMS, Ceipal AI and workforce management in one platform, with healthcare solutions covering credentialing, compliance and invoicing. It reports 2,500+ clients and does not publish pricing.
Front-to-back staffing suites: Avionté and JobDiva
Avionté describes itself as end-to-end staffing and recruiting software in a single platform: CRM, ATS, payroll, billing, reporting and mobile talent engagement, with AI embedded in pre-screening and interviews. It references light industrial and healthcare staffing, reports $15 billion in payroll processed a year, and is based in Bloomington, Minnesota. Pricing is by demo.
JobDiva calls itself a global applicant tracking system and front-to-back talent management solution, with a CRM, onboarding, the DivaFinancials back office suite and VMS synchronization. It is based in New York, reports 40,000+ recruiters on the platform, and does not publish pricing.
Ployo platform data
30,000+
AI Interviews Completed
340,000+
Candidate Answers Graded
70%+
Interview Completion Rate
15,000+
Recruiter Hours Saved
Running Ployo alongside a staffing platform
Plenty of agencies will keep their staffing platform for credentialing, time and pay and billing, and that is the right call. The split that works is clean: Ployo interviews every applicant and records the evidence; the staffing platform handles the placement, the compliance file and the pay run. How Ployo's results reach another system is set up with each customer, so bring your stack to the demo rather than assuming a connector.
Bullhorn is the system that runs a staffing agency. Ployo is the part that talks to applicants. An agency that needs timesheets, payroll and billing should keep a staffing platform, and can run Ployo alongside it for the first round. An agency or desk whose problem is screening speed can run Ployo as its tracker and stop booking first-round calls altogether.
Bullhorn is a layer 0 tool: the ats knockout and resume screen. Software reads the application and rejects most of them before any person is involved. See how the six layers of first-round screening fit together →
Frequently asked
What are the best Bullhorn alternatives for healthcare staffing?
If you need a full platform with credentialing, VMS and payroll, LaborEdge is built for healthcare staffing, and Ceipal and Avionté run front and back office. If your problem is screening speed, Ployo is the strongest option: an applicant tracking system with an AI video interviewer that interviews every applicant the day they apply, from US$249 a month.
Does Ployo do timesheets, payroll or billing?
No. Ployo does not do timesheets, payroll, rostering, client billing or VMS. It covers intake, CV matching, the AI video interview, the verdict and candidate stages to hire. Agencies that need back office keep a staffing platform for it.
How much does Bullhorn cost?
Bullhorn publishes two prices, Starter at $99 and Core at $165 per user per month. Every larger edition, including Front Office Enterprise and Bullhorn One, is quote only. Ployo publishes all its plans in US dollars from $249 a month and does not charge per seat.
Can Ployo check nursing licences or credentials?
Ployo asks the candidate about each registration or check in the interview and records the answer as evidence. It does not verify licences, registrations or background checks with the issuing body; that stays with your credentialing process.
Can I use Ployo with the staffing system I already have?
Yes. Some teams run Ployo as their tracker; others use it for the front of the funnel and keep their staffing platform for placements, compliance and pay. How results reach another system is set up with each customer.
Sources
Facts about other products come from their own public pages, checked on the dates below. Vendors change pricing and features without notice, so verify anything decision-critical at the source. Found something out of date? Tell us and we'll correct it.
- Bullhorn homepage: AI recruitment ATS and CRM powering 10,000+ staffing agencies, Amplify, Boston, middle and back office · checked 2026-09-10
- Bullhorn healthcare staffing page: credentialing, time and pay, shift scheduling, provider portal, 22 of the top 25 healthcare staffing agencies · checked 2026-09-10
- Bullhorn pricing page: Starter at $99 and Core at $165 per user per month (Core re-checked 2026-09-13), larger editions quote only · checked 2026-09-10
- LaborEdge homepage: healthcare ATS, VMS, mobile and payroll, Novi, Michigan · checked 2026-09-10
- Ceipal homepage: Staffing OS, ATS, VMS, healthcare credentialing and invoicing, 2,500+ clients · checked 2026-09-10
- Avionté homepage: end-to-end staffing software, payroll and billing, Bloomington, Minnesota · checked 2026-09-10
- JobDiva homepage: ATS, DivaFinancials back office, VMS synchronization, New York · checked 2026-09-10
Most of what decides this is your own role, not the feature grid. Worked examples of AI screening applied to specific sectors are on the solutions pages, and the practical how-to side, including what compliance actually requires before someone starts a shift, is in the hiring guides.
If you would rather see the mechanics than read about them, the AI video interviewer page walks through an interview end to end.
Related comparisons
TRUSTED BY HIRING TEAMS AT
The only comparison that settles it
Run it on your own applicants. Book 30 minutes with the founder, we'll set Ployo up on a role you're hiring for right now, and you can judge the shortlist yourself.
30-minute call · See Ployo on one of your live roles